Dimsum masthead
Home arrow Life in China arrow The environmental benefits of vegetarianism
The environmental benefits of vegetarianism PDF Print E-mail
China
Friday, 31 October 2008

china dialogueThere is no need to recount the litany of China's environmental disasters; catastrophes such as the blue-green algae that choked Taihu Lake appear daily on our TV screens and in our newspapers. Protecting our environment may today be the biggest challenge that faces humanity.

Many will turn to science for a solution. But reality demonstrates that relying on science alone will not lead to success. Unless we change our lifestyles, scientific advances will only accelerate damage to the environment.

It would take a day to fell a large tree in the past, and it would be months or even years before that tree was turned into processed wood and used to construct buildings in a far-off city. But now the lumber industry can flatten entire forests in very little time, and have the wood converted into floors and furniture in a matter of days. We do not have the respect and awe for nature that, in other times, held what little industrial capacity there was in check. The loss of this "superstition", combined with the driving force of capitalism, has meant nothing now restrains us from using our technology to squeeze every last drop of profit from nature.

In certain respects, vegetarianism is a higher moral choice. It avoids the killing and enslavement of animals, and it helps protect the environment. The converting of fodder to meat involves massive waste - any given area of land can support 20 times as many vegetarians as meat-eaters. South America's tropical rainforests are being felled to provide pasture for livestock - and even these pastures are not used in a sustainable manner and are quickly abandoned. Every hamburger results in the loss of around 6.25 cubic metres of forest.

But industrialised farming doesn't only cause suffering to animals - it also creates massive amounts of pollution. Figures show that every kilogram of beef requires 10,000 litres of water and produces 40 kilograms of excrement. More dung is produced than the environment can cope with, and since it cannot all be used as fertiliser it ends up in the natural world.

Industrial farming is a burden for an already fragile ecology; it has increased the numbers of cattle and the methane they produce, which is a significant contributor to global warming. It has led to the accumulation of harmful chemicals in ever-longer food chains; the appearance of pharmaceutical additives in animal fodder; and the loss of topsoil due to over-grazing.

History shows that our current lifestyles and values are not conducive to solving these environmental issues. Yet if we adjusted our ways, this could be done. Vegetarians, simply by resisting the temptations of meat, can avoid contributing to these problems.

Giving up meat may seem like a grim prospect to many, but really it is not so bad. Vegetarians are more healthy and vigorous than their meat-eating counterparts. Ten-time Olympic medal winner Carl Lewis is a vegetarian, along with many successful athletes in fields where endurance is key, such as cycling, long-distance running and swimming. In many western countries, vegetarianism is common among those who take care of their health, and it is a fashionable choice for the young.

Many people in China today misunderstand vegetarianism; they confuse the conscious decision to refuse meat - for the sake of the environment and animal welfare - with the enforced vegetarianism of poverty. The latter diet is, of course, unhealthy. However, this is due the inadequate, monotonous and unbalanced diet that poverty brings, rather than the lack of meat in itself. Vegetarianism as a choice, with an adequate and balanced nutritional intake, is a perfectly healthy option.

However, many people still find it an unpalatable option, and feel the diet cannot satisfy their taste for meat. Generations of Chinese cuisine have made meat-eating a strong part of our culture, and a vegetarian diet seems like an inferior choice. But pay a bit more attention to the culinary arts, and the flavour of vegetarian cooking is in no way second-rate. First-time diners at vegetarian restaurants are often surprised at how good a meat-free meal can taste. Vegetarian restaurants in China have a long history of producing meals designed to mimic the taste and texture of meat - a godsend for those recent converts who still lust for that meaty taste. And there is no need to be strictly vegetarian all the time; you can choose the degree and duration of your commitment as it suits your lifestyle.

China's tradition of Buddhism means vegetarianism once had a strong following. But today we have a lower percentage of vegetarians than western countries. There are many reasons for this, one being the low-level of education about the environmental benefits of meat-free living, another being the general lack of ecological awareness. However, Peking University founded its Vegetarian Society in 2000, and a number of leading universities now have groups advocating the rejection of meat. Vegetarianism is an up-and-coming youth movement in China, promoted by those with a sense of social and environmental responsibility. It has a bright future, and people who care about the environment should pay attention - and maybe even join us.

Article by JIngSong Jiang. Reprinted with kind permission of chinadialogue - an independent, non-commercial, bilingual website devoted to the publication of high quality information and debate on the environment.

 
Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
pensggs - vegetarianism Posted 12:21 on 2 November 2008
These days, vegetarianism does not equal 'social and environmental' responsibility. In today's world, the 'perfect fruit and vegetables' are grown with 'environmental costs'.

1. Transport equals pollution
2. Intensive farming methods equals environmental disasters; look at the old world, today suffering from depletion of the land; caused by historical exploitation of land for 'production of vegetarian products.
3. Use of 'fertilisers' and 'chemical agents' in the growing of fruits and vegetables. In HK, vegetables and fruits grown in China, are constantly being rejected for failing the 'safety' tests.
4. The 'unknown' and 'unproven' use of the 'GM' technology on the inhabitants of 'Mother Earth'.
5. The unhealthy use of chemical enhancers and 'food additives' in the industrial produced vegetarian products. In fact, research existed whereby 'celebrity approved' vegetarian products contained far too much saturated fats.
6. The question to be answered for me personally is 'why' are 'animals' that are 'vegetarian' so large; and some even had 'two stomachs' to process the 'vegetarian' products.

The 'band wagon' of vegetarianism is definitely being hailed as 'healthy'. However,to be a 'environmentally conscientious and humanity onscientious' advocate of 'vegetarianism, one needs to do further research.

My demised grandmother who hailed from Southern China, used to allocate two days a month as 'non meat days'. It was her way to pay 'penance' for the 'taking of another life' for the food. In those days, only vegetable products produced by herself were used; and only vegetables grown locally were used.
If all the meat eaters are persuaded to do the same, just imagine 'how many green points' are being achieved.

So, before we advocate 'vegetarianism' as the vehicle for a healthy lifestyle or as a 'green vehicle'; more research is needed. I have yet to be convinced.
Hot Chinese Chips - I LIKE MEAT Posted 12:33 on 5 November 2008
I like meat, freshly sliced from a cow, and grilled to medium rare perfection.

As a Chinese man, I enjoy eating a variety of animals - pigs, cows, chicken, etc

I agree with pensggs, there's no evidence to suggest that farming cute animals to eat is bad for the environment. Agriculture consumes a lot of land, intensive farming caused all the plagues of ancient Egypt by deforestation.
Flik_8 - Responsible farming is key, bu Posted 15:04 on 6 November 2008
I am not a veggie, but I can't live without it. Equally, I can't live without that taste of meat either.

When you have industrial farming in any country, the farmers themselves need to have a feel for that responsibility. It is not just about mass production and profitability.

This may support the thoughts of organic farming. However, under EU laws, it is actually very difficult to ensure that "organic" means what we think "organic" should be.

Besides, Marco Pierre White said in a recent interview, "Tesco must flog 50 million chickens a week. To make them all free range, we'd be an island full of chickens...Every field would have a chicken in it."

And that's just one supermarket. How many jobs will then transfer over to farmers who choose to grow vegetables because we have all gone vegetarian?

You might think if you don't pack thousands of chicken in a warehouse, then that's got to be good.

The food producers will respond to growing vegetables with some form of super fertiliser? Pack more vegetables into per square metre.

How you cook the vegetables will also be important. Make it all into tempura and suddenly, it's not such a healthy lifestyle.

When I see these people who eats a big greasy meal with a diet coke, makes me chuckle! Ok, I get it, it's balancing the overall calorie input.

Even a better one is to be the hip girls and guys who rather be a vegetarian, because it compliments that healthy lifestyle, with their Marlboro lights in one hand and a vodka diet coke in the other.

Life is full of irony. And yes, I am probably overweight, couch potato...but I love it.
Primate Posted 17:16 on 6 November 2008
Could laboratory-manufactured, bio-engineered beef be a solution?

If so, even snake stir-fry, dog meat ginger-and-spring onions, and cat broth can all be eaten without assault on the conscience!

China could easily ramp up its Bio-engineering technology! That also certainly buries the circular argument over chicken-and-egg scenarios.....
FLESH EATER - MEAT... Posted 11:47 on 7 November 2008
Meat tastes better when the animal has been freshly slaughtered.
Edwina Lee Posted 23:02 on 4 December 2008
Here's a quick calculator for the amount of land required for different types of food:-

http://environment.uk.msn.com/interactive/Vegetarian.aspx

Vegetarianism has a very small footprint compared to meat eating. It is going to make a lot of land owners bankrupt! :D
Vege Music Woman - meat Posted 23:52 on 30 March 2009
Hot Chinese Chips may well enjoy his meat, but "no evidence about farming animals to eat is bad for the environment". How many acres of land do you think are used to provide food for these animals? It's a well known fact that acre for acre, growing food for humans, rather than food for animals which humans will then consume, is a much better option.
sallylily - protecting our environmrnt Posted 5:18 on 20 October 2009
Though animals eat vegetables and if all people are vegetarians, we can feed more people. but meat is also important, we need the nutrition
provided by meat. there are also some good things in China www.char4u.com
Leanda - Raise your awareness Posted 14:43 on 13 December 2009
Meat - a cute name for flesh or gore is addictive. It breaks down to protein, then into nitrosamine in the system. It is like adrenaline & is a stimulant & not a food. So is caffeine & amphetamine. variations on a theme, some things speed you up & some slow you down. The average steak contains approx 14 grams of uric acid & the kidneys can only process around 1 gram per day. The rest settles out in the joints causing problems. Even dogs only eat approx 10-20% meat-they eat berries, eggs & will eat fruits & nuts. I have been a vegetarian for 35yrs & a vegan for 20yrs. I eat predominantely raw salad & fruit. I am alway's told I don't look my age. Besides we are human animals & we just don't speak various animal language. We are so speciest that we put ourselves up on a pedistal to justify that we are killing. The biggest & the strongest animals on the planet are vegetarian & none of them needs a frying pan & a fire. I have fasted many times -once for 40 day's on grapes-never felt better in my entire life-full of energy. Hardly needed any sleep, my thoughts were crystal clear. As for the health issues, well earlier in the year UK research showed that a vegetarian diet was optimum, & that the body could really only cope with a piece of steak the size of a pack of playing cards. We are light creatures first & foremost, we hide away from the sun (ever see animals with sunblock & hat's on) & it is what provides us with vitamin D-then we go & buy it in a bottle. Our bodies convert fresh optimum fruits & vegetables into what we need & only because we don't get enough light. Chloryphyl is the closest thing to haemaglobin, that's why mozzies like blood & sit on plants when they can't get it as there is very little difference. I can back most of these claims up. We lower our immune systems with what we call food & wonder why we are ill claiming we have caught something.
Write comment
Name:
Subject:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
If you are unable to read the security code, please send your comment to This email address is being protected from spam bots, you need Javascript enabled to view it .
Security Code:
Type the code in the image
(helps prevent spam)
Security Image