Home arrow Viewpoints arrow Cannes Controversy: Sharon Stone’s china quake bad “karma” comments
Cannes Controversy: Sharon Stone’s china quake bad “karma” comments PDF Print E-mail
Viewpoints
Saturday, 31 May 2008

Sharon StoneControversy usually hits the Cannes Film Festival from what is shown on the big screen. However, this year at the 61st International Cannes Film Festival, some off-colour comments about the recent earthquake in China by American actress Sharon Stone is creating a media storm that could possibly overshadow the ritzy event.

Sharon Stone, best known for starring in the movie Basic Instinct, had actually been hot off the praises of many for her fundraising efforts for amfAR, The Foundation for AIDS Research. During the charity auction, that took place alongside of the film festival, Stone along with her celebrity friends, which included A-listers like Madonna, P. Diddy, and Natalie Portman to name a few, collectively help raise $10 million dollars for paediatric AIDS research.

Soon after this philanthropic triumph, according to the Guardian, Stone was quoted as saying that the recent Sichuan earthquake, which has killed 67,000 people so far, may in a way be in result of bad "karma" for possible human rights offenses by the Chinese government in its treatment of the Tibetan people.

Stone, who counts the Dalai Lama as a personal friend, also expressed her displeasure of the treatment of the Dalai Lama by the Chinese authorities.

"I've been concerned about how should we deal with the Olympics, because they are not being nice to the Dalai Lama, who is a good friend of mine," she said.

During an interview with reporters at Cannes, Stone was not afraid to voice her belief that the Sichuan earthquake may in a way be retribution for the mistreatment of the Tibetan people at the hands of the Chinese.

"And then all this earthquake and all this stuff happened, and I thought, is that karma?" Stone said. "When you're not nice that the bad things happen to you?"

Because of her statements, Stone has effectively jeopardized her future in the Chinese media market, where along with her films, she had also been featured in ad campaigns for Christian Dior. According to Clifford Coonan of The Independent, Stone has remained a popular star in China and had been warmly received at the Shanghai Film Festival last year, ironically giving comments of praise about China's ancient civilization.

Stone's comments have also greatly offended the chairman of the Federation of Hong Kong Filmmakers and founder of the UME Cineplex chain, Ng See-Yuen.

Ng is now banning the showing of Stone's present and future films in his cinema chain, which can be found in Hong Kong, Beijing, and Shanghai, as he has stated to The Beijing Times that he thought her words about the quake were "inappropriate" considering the tragic circumstances. China's Xinhua news agency has also labelled Stone as "the public enemy of all mankind".

Additionally, Stone's image was immediately removed from the advertising materials for Christian Dior in department stores in the Beijing and Shanghai, and according to the PR company for Dior she has been dropped from promoting their anti-ageing skincare line in China.

Dior has also issued an apology to the its customers in China to separate itself from their embattled spokesman.

"We just want our customers and fans to realise that her personal comments are not related to the company," the company said. "And of course we don't support any type of commentary that will hurt the feelings of our customers.

In the wake of the controversy, Stone has stepped forward and issued her own apology for her comments. Stating that she is "deeply sorry" for any pain that her words have caused to the Chinese people, to make amends she has also said she is would work with the earthquake relief efforts.

"Due to my inappropriate words and acts during the interview, I feel deeply sorry and sad about hurting Chinese people," Stone said. She later stated she would also "wholly devote myself to helping affected Chinese people".

Questionable is the word as to whether or not Stone's apology will be able to salvage her career in China as a movie star and brand front-woman. But in the end, some ill-timed words may show that bad "karma" can cut both ways.

See Stone's comments on YouTube here.

Pamela Yau

Image Courtesy of Siebbi

 
Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
Bill - Sharon Stone Posted 17:04 on 1 June 2008
In her interview, Sharon Stone said that she had learned a big lesson, now that turns out to be true - a costly lesson of at least US$50 million contract and an end of her career if she ever had one. Her words have united the Chinese worldwide in an unbelievable way that is something she never expected. God says that "don't judge others as others will judge you". These words are realized in thousands fold. For someone with IQ at 154, it is hard to believe that she can be such an idiot, probably she thinks that she is somebody and is up high there to overlook other human beings. To judge them and to save them. This time, the most important thing is how to save herself. Obviously, if Hollywood wishes to distribute any movies in China, they got to think again who they chose to play in the movie. Ms. Stone, you are 50, why do you still have an IQ of a kindergarten kid? Shame on you.
becbec Posted 18:02 on 2 June 2008
I think Sharon Stone should learn not only to shut her basic instinct legs but her mouth aswell.

You have to be so careful what to say these days, maybe that s why not many media celebs have come forward concerning the sad events of the earthquake (most people i believe do actually care and do have compassion and would help if they can); because one slip of the tongue can kill your career stone dead, pardon the pun.
anomymous - Sharon is right Posted 20:48 on 2 June 2008
I sincerely thank Miss Stone for expressing her concerns about the injustice that occurs in China. Perhaps the earthquake is really a retribution from the God to punish Chinese people for their cruelty and insensibility toward Tibet's people.

Chinese government and her supporters, due to their own selfishness, brutally oppressed the freedom of speech and the human right in Tibet. If they don't get what they deserve, it is unfair.

Don't expect people to have mercy on you when you don't have mercy on the others.

Someone said "Tibet was liberated the presants in Xizang eat Dalai lama's sh*t." Compare this with how Mr. Bush liberates Iraq after 9/11 for oil. If Chinese have no other intention, Chinese should have left Tibet after liberating her.

Don't say that you Chinese people are helping Tibetan. It is insulting. Moreover, your helps have never been enough. Now get the hell out of there.
quietman Posted 1:15 on 3 June 2008
I think you should get the hell out of here 'anonymous'.
Calmman Posted 1:20 on 3 June 2008
I think there is a reason for 'anonymous', coz Mr./Mrs. can't be responsible of what s/he is saying?
Kyu Posted 16:01 on 3 June 2008
amituofo
bbc Posted 21:18 on 3 June 2008
my hunch its all spin, including here...
BBC female - Sharon Stone Posted 14:47 on 4 June 2008
Presumably Sharon Stone also believes that Karma was also to answer for the 9/11 atrocity, Cyclone Nargis and Sharon's own fight with breast cancer then? Or does Karma only affect Chinese people??! Deary me, the stupidity of some famous people beggars belief.
Jeff Minter Posted 19:50 on 4 June 2008
Having thought about this long and hard...



I still would.

But c'mon, anyone taking the political views of an ACTOR seriously is a retard themselves - you know, the sort who needs the TV and newspaper to tell them what to think.
Yin Posted 19:39 on 6 June 2008
@anonymous, whoever the f*** you are.

So Sorry for my crude language.
I'm sorry, who ended serfdom, who built hospitals and transportation around Tibet?
Don't criticise the Chinese government for not doing enough.

And please don't scream the words 'no mercy' so easily. If we had no mercy, China's patience would have run out long ago. But no, the chinese government are putting the rescue effort first.

sharon stone, plus anyone who undermines the death of 69,000 people has no heart, brain or conscience, and I hope Karma deals you a bad hand in life.

Thanks
lams - caution Posted 17:11 on 9 June 2008
I think "anonymous comments are meant to provoke anger or stir controversy for whatever reason, rather than a real concern for Tibet situation, which i am not dismissive of.
Of course free speech is very important and "spin" is inevitably a part of the media output; but my only concern is that there are BBC/chinese people who take the bait too easily.
Cassie - mmm Posted 0:36 on 31 July 2008
Initially I was more than outraged at Sharon Stone's comments! Having calmed down and watched the interview online however, I think she prob meant to give a message of forgiveness- how Tibetans were kind despite the damages done by the Chinese... (have to grudingly admit that the Tibetans hadn't had the best treatment...but the situation is far more complex than is depicted on British TV) but it all came out wrong!

I also have to question the timing of her remarks...they are still wholly insensitive and I think, cruel. She can "wonder" and questions things but what she said was completely unacceptable to the victims. So yeh, echoing what someone said earlier, apologies warranted.
Kiwinese - Sharon just wants to share her Posted 11:11 on 22 August 2008
Which orifice did she speak out of? What sort of intelligence do you expect from someone best known for lower body part promotion?
medialies - tolerance Posted 1:15 on 5 December 2008
WOW, just looking at the comments here show us how intolerant and hypocritical people are. Stone's comments were taken out of context and that has been proven but lets not dwell on that. Lets look at the hypocrisy, most of the people here were probably talking about the need to protect free speech pre 1997 in HK and yet when someone, no matter now ridiculously ignorant, says something that they do not like your true characters come out ie "shut your legs". Where is our Voltaire, I quote "I may disagree with what you say but I shall defend to the death your right to say it." Where indeed.
Write comment
Name:
Subject:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
Security Code:
Type the code in the image
(helps prevent spam)
Security Image
 
< Prev   Next >