Home arrow Viewpoints arrow Chinese in Britain - Advancing Social Cohesion
Chinese in Britain - Advancing Social Cohesion PDF Print E-mail
Viewpoints
Saturday, 13 October 2007
With the season of conferences of the main political parties over and the fever of a snap general election extinguished by the Prime Minister, I have had time to reflect on the future of the Chinese community in Britain.

The Chinese presence in British cities seems to be noticeably increasing of late, but more significantly, this appears to be due to greater influx of Chinese from mainland China, compared with those who are of Commonwealth origins and those who are born here.

The globalisation of migratory pressures has seen both positive and negative impacts on Britain and elsewhere. Of the latter variety, the rise of indigenous and importation of Islamic fundamentalism have focussed the attention of the British people on the destabilising aspects of immigration and of multiracialism.

Thankfully and much to the credit of our Chinese community, we have never been involved in anything of such a scale, and I am confident we will never be found wanting in doing everything required of us to preserve the good order of society here. In particular, we pride ourselves in being hard-working and law-abiding, and our children are consistently held up as exemplars of educational achievement. Indeed, the more recent Chinese entrants are largely students, professionals and workers, all of whom are net contributors to the British society.

I myself arrived in Britain from Malaysia some thirty-five years ago. In that time, I read medicine and law, married and now have three children. But for the burgeoning difficulties in the NHS, I would have been quite contented to continue dedicating my life to my vocation. Rising to the challenge, I sought solutions in politics.

But there is more to politics than health, although it would seem to be a natural progression. Becoming involved in politics has made me aware of my own personal background. At the last General Election, media crews showed interest in my campaign in Bradford, not so much from a party perspective, but from that of a Chinese candidate.

To me, that media interest epitomises the belief that the Chinese community in Britain has reached a historically critical point in their citizenship. Various dignitaries in the Chinese community I have spoken with, notably Miss Christine Lee, Mr Lee Kam Yee, Mr Edmond Yeo and Mr Ng Heng, all share my view that we now need to progress beyond having only surrogate parliamentary representation.

A substantial, direct and credible Chinese participation in the political arena of British society is, I believe, overdue. Let's awaken ourselves to this new endeavour!

© Dr. T K Khong
 
Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
pensggs - Social cohesion & representati Posted 12:31 on 14 October 2007
It has generally been 'said' amongst the Chinese worldwide that 'A chinese person is very self centred, therefore, not a natural community centred or conscious person.' When they built a school in China in the village of their ancestors, they are showing the community that they are successful, so that their ancestors can be proud of them. This is the extension of the Confucius teaching rather than a personal desire to help the less fortunate or the community. The same psyche operates wherever they migrate too unless the chinese psyche has been inflitrated by another culture.

Take the recent case of the 'Chinese Community Leader' being caught with money laundering in Hong Kong. Who he is and how he operates is well known in the Chinese community, yet he has been allowed by the purported leaders of the Chinese community and representatives to represent you and me. If influential chinese community leaders allowed 'corrupt' procedures to elect our representatives and leaders, our credibility and integrity as a Chinese in UK, will continue to suffer a lack of representation by professional, ethical and socially responsible persons.

Chinese in Britain comes from diverse cultural, political and educational background.' This makes cohesion difficult especially there is mutual distrust and dislike. Until we have social and political leaders, who works for the community without 'self interest' and 'personal agenda', the Chinese community will continue to be sidelined by the host community.

In my experience in working with the Chinese community, I find that people who have a 'personal agenda' have been more successfull in becoming 'so-call' representatives of the Chinese community, for example, the recent case of Mr. He and last year the case of Mr. Chan. Both use the Chinese community for their own agenda. Until and unless we clean our own house, the Chinese community will continue to suffer an 'image' problem.

Personally I have been approached by some influential host community leaders to volunteer for public office, however, I had decided to decline. This is because within the host community, there continues to be an institutionised discrimination and racism influence in its political, economical and social policies. To fight one's corner sometimes one must put one's head above the paraquet and posibility get 'shot'. By not being a public person, I feel more able to use 'all available tools' to fight injustice whenever I encounter it without bringing disrepute to the image of the 'Chinese person'. There is a time and a place.

I 'raise' my hat to you for deciding that the next 'phrase' of your life that you have decided to represent the Chinese in politics. However as a public person, I look forward to you using your knowledge of the NHS ( a dinosaur in terms of institutionised discriminatory and racist attitude in its operational, recruitment and management policies) to represent not only Chinese but the 'unrepresented' communities in Britian. It is when each ethnic community leaders work together for the good of society that the host community will listen.

Please see yourself as a political leader of the 'unrepresented'. It is this attitude that will allow the Chinese person to get on the political leader. The current political system have 'structural barriers' for entry and safeguard the 'continued political power base' of the white community.
JJWoah! Posted 19:07 on 14 October 2007
I think that many BBCs here in this country have thought about getting into politics or into the media. Indeed, we should have more MPs that are from ethnic minorities in general and not just Chinese. But getting into the media and the general view of the public is equally important if we want to have representation.

Just getting a Chinese face into the public eye is usually quite a feat and I often find myself getting the whole family to watch TV whenever a Chinese person is on. Ok, so compared to other ethnic groups we are tiny in number but it doesn't mean we shouldn't be on screen or in the media more often. A large part of the problem is first generation parents pushing their children into becoming doctors and lawyers. Getting into showbiz doesn't give you a secure job and don't even think about getting into politics because they're all racist and you'll get nowhere.

This way of thinking should start disappearing as the first generation makes way for the more westernised second and with that comes the dreams of becoming a politician, an actor, or a footballer etc.

However, once you're noticed, it can be easier to get criticised as your negatives are equally as highlighted as your positives. Do we want the media on our backs like it is on Muslims? Can we risk it? It could, of course, go the other way and there could be less "blind racism" such as constant reference to takeaways. But the large rise of immigrants from China could cause problems. Already, there has been a rise in crackdowns on Chinese illegal workers in my area and it may damage our reputation with others. We need to be careful about this but it should not prevent us from getting our faces in Westminster and on TV. In fact, I get the feeling that relations would be better if we were around more.

Representation not only in Parliament, but also elsewhere, is long overdue. The younger generations will surely fill this gap but it could make us more vulnerable to criticism. Our reputation as hard-working and law-abiding could be in danger but I've come to the conclusion that to minimise this risk we should get out there and get involved.

I also "raise my hat" to you for getting into politics. Lead the way and I'm sure more will follow.
Anonymous Posted 22:58 on 14 October 2007
Dear pensggs and JJWoah!,

Thank you both very much for your general comments and sincere advice, hoping that you would not mind a combined response to your feedback as they are complementary.

I do not have any personal or private agenda in politics, as my late entry would testify to that. Having worked in the NHS for so many years and realising what good it has achieved and so much more that can be done, I have tried to contribute to its improvement through professional bodies and committees, but they add up to nothing as politicisation of the NHS is so overwhelming and the structure is widely flawed. I may not have all the answers, but I am willing to give it my best shot!

In many ways and according to various advice, a Chinese seeking a political role in the UK is on to a tough hiding. I could be accused of being a "sanitised" Sino-Anglophile as alluded to in the feedback, and such a remark would equally be applicable to a non-racial approach. However, my record of dedication to public service and professionalism in its discharge regardless of class or race is a reliable indication of the purity of my politics. Indeed, when all is said and done, I may find that I am not accepted into the political arena but at least I can then say that I have tried and I still have a role to play in my profession.

Yours sincerely,

T K Khong
Roger - Social cohesion & representati Posted 14:57 on 15 October 2007
I've said it before, and I'll say it again, there is nothing stopping british chinesers getting on tv other than british chinesers. Sure, it's hard to get elected or get on TV but, believe it or not, it's hard for everyone. The members of the chinese community seem to just give up at the first hurdle, and then frustrate everyone else by blaming them for not letting achieve their goal. Believe me, I'd welcome some more communities in parliament, it might make it more interesting for the rest of us. So 'chinese community' get out there and do it!
pensggs - social cohesion & representati Posted 18:31 on 15 October 2007
Dear Roger,

Positive thinking is great. Realistic and analytical reasoning stops you wasting your energy. Passion and Belief can get you through locked doors, as long as you have the energy to continue springing up with every knocks. However, I have yet to meet an indestructible human being or machine.

Basketball is easy for the 'Globetrotters'. Put a 5ft Chinaman against these 6ft over 'Globetrotters', and see how they scoop the basketball out of the net. This is the same as a Chinaman trying to get into the media or parliament.

I suppose you will then blame the Chinaman for not trying.
Anonymous Posted 18:34 on 11 January 2008
Hi Pensggs,

Just for the record, there are quite a few Chinese NBL stars in the States... :)
duckegg - comments Posted 19:40 on 15 October 2007
peneggs (top), some good comments,

i also think the situation is further complicated by "econ/social/educational" differences and situation within the chinese community itself, ie articulate middle class professionals and working class catering workers... often they have different agendas and aspirations. Majority of the chinese community are not middle class but lower.

... interesting debate
T K Khong Posted 23:16 on 15 October 2007
Over time, I would expect the current preponderance of any one socio-economic group over the others to even out, and especially with the Chinese emphasis on education, a growing intelligentsia would emerge.

Another development that would not be an unreasonable expectation is the facile integration of the upwardly and socially mobile not only into mainstream British society but also their entry into the upper echelons without so much as a song and dance, as the fundamental racial characteristic is self-effacement.

The big question is not whether but when there would be serious engagement by the Chinese in British politics. History would suggest that any success would be cultivated along the lines of the West, with Chinese interests becoming muted or private. Indeed, the essence of successful integration is the embodiment of inner and private cultural values and the conduct of civic duties and public functions in the Western idiom.
Jeff Posted 5:52 on 21 October 2007
penseggs has it in a nutshell. The lines to success are obviously wide apart regarding your race... or rather, whether you are chinese or not.

Even in these times of racial tension, we still regard black, asian people as british more than that of their "homeland"...

Par example... I was in the town hall the other day...sat next to me was a black lady, when a white woman from behind me comes up and asks me if she needed a ticket for the queue. As I turned my head she simply ignored me, under the assumption that I couldn't understand [along with some other thoughts of leeching, asylum seeking etc. no doubt] and asked the black lady instead, who in fact had worse off English that I did, with an obvious Caribbean accent.

This is reflected in the article writer's experiences when campaigning... he got attention from his race, rather than his policies/what he was standing for. Believe me, this gets impossibly infuriating when all you want to do is make a case, but are sidetracked with "racial loyalty" questions, and how you being chinese can affect your stance.

Note that this doesn't apply to black people, even asians... who was that black woman MP recently ousted in London by Galloway? She stood for support for schools, not once was she questioned about her race.

Ditto too for Lewis Hamilton... he's a Brit first, his race is just a casual point of little significance. That, I don't get at all... since the ethnic minorities only settled in Britain in roughly the same time period (50-100 years ago), surely we're just as British as them?
Wai - Hoohah Posted 22:45 on 27 October 2007
I commend you on your efforts and am all for bringing the chinese community together, for far too long we have been the subject of our own selfishness, not just lacking in cohesion but actively seeking dispersion.

I support you in your endeavor.

Wai
T K Khong Posted 2:15 on 29 October 2007
Thank you Wai for your kind support. I am sincere and passionate about dispelling the stereotyping of the Chinese people, and advancing their participation in mainstream British society.

I hope my perseverance will triumph!
Oksource Posted 21:33 on 6 November 2007
TK Khong. Good luck with your endeavor. Whatever you do you would be breaking new grounds! You will be bringing your own character to life but whatever you do try not to be labeled as another wax work! May the force be with you but if you do go over the dark side do not try the obvious such as Snake head; Tong; Ming the evil Emperor; Colonial Kampong leftover; Blood sucking opium smoking undead; bourgeois landlord, it is so uncool.
Derek H Posted 23:20 on 22 January 2008
Speaking as a white person born in the UK with an immigrant mother and UK born father I have seen the change in the British society as a whole in its attitude to race & racism.

I agree that there's institutional racism still and that the older UK generation harbour some racist "values" but I believe on the whole that race/colour has become less important. If I compare the UK to most other countries I've visited and/or lived in I think it's pretty open and fair. Of course, I'm not black, Asian, Chinese or whatever so could never know first hand your experiences, if negative. My fiancee from HK has never had a bad experience thus far in the UK though.

And to speak rather delicately about a very crude matter (please forgive the tone of this in advance) if one looks at all the ethnic groups in the UK I have very very rarely heard bad words said about the Chinese. Many times I've heard ignorant BS about blacks and Indians/Pakistanis (although this is definitely becoming less and less, thank God). I have heard more bad words said about the Irish and being half Irish these words can hurt. Again, I hear this kind of racist rubbish less and less all the time now too.

I agree that there are very few Chinese/Orientals in the media. I can think of only a handful:

Gok Wan - presents the excellent Look Good Naked show

Pui Fan Lee - presenter on CBeebies Channel (BBC)

Well, ok..not a handful, just 2

Playing devil's advocate, is this a fair proportion based on the number of Chinese in the UK? My understanding is that there are 250,000 Chinese living in UK right now. The UK pop is 65M. This means that the Chinese makes up 0.0038%

Would these 2 Chinese TV presenters be greater than 0.0038% of people who are on TV?

No idea (well, I think the answer would be there would have to be 520 presenters on UK TV)...anyway, the point of writing this was to say I don't see any reason why you can't make it. To hell with the old school racists...get yourself out there, be prepared for the multiple rejections and keep going. It's hard work and I don't think you'd get the rejections based on your ethnicity.
Write comment
Name:
Subject:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
Security Code:
Type the code in the image
(helps prevent spam)
Security Image
 
< Prev   Next >