Home arrow Viewpoints arrow Chinese representation in British politics
Chinese representation in British politics PDF Print E-mail
Viewpoints
Thursday, 29 May 2008

The background to the quest for a Chinese MP

In the United Kingdom, the Chinese community ranks low in the classification by ethnicity. There is a feeling, however, that even accounting for their small numbers in the overall population, the Chinese in Britain are under-represented in certain areas of British society and none more so than in politics.

The lack of a Chinese MP at Westminster may well be due to a near absence of Chinese involvement in British politics, and it may be argued in reverse that there is little incentive for the major political parties to engage the Chinese community in politics because of these reasons.

Education and developments in the wider world have now created awareness amongst the Chinese in Britain for recognition and belonging. The primordial sense of racial pride is boosted by the rising status of China in the international arena, and although citizenry and nationalism are different issues, the emotional and cultural linkages are immutable and bind the Chinese in Britain.

The contribution of British Chinese to the national economy is difficult to quantify, as there is probably a significant element of anonymity and diffidence that is a hallmark of the Chinese people. More visible forms of Chinese participation in British life include catering and specialty food stores, with professional positions such as medicine, dentistry and law being less conspicuous. However, relative to their numbers, the Chinese have contributed enormously to Britain.

The stage is therefore set for the Chinese to engage in national politics as an integral part of a cohesive and modern Britain. Furthermore, while this is a natural progression and a mark of their role in British society, their benefit to the strategic position of Britain in relation to the global importance of China cannot be over-emphasised.

The nuances of British politics

Critical to the establishment of a political profile for the Chinese is the acceptance that their numbers are low in comparison to other ethnic groups, and the dominance of the mainstream White Anglo-Saxons in an essentially Western European nation with a history of global colonisation. This is expressed plainly in a sympathy remark from the wife of a Chinese who felt a predominantly white selection committee would have difficulty anointing a Chinese parliamentary candidate, let alone a white community electing a Chinese MP. The point made there is not negative or racist; it is a disarmingly realistic viewpoint of the frustrating situation.

Furthermore, Chinese groups largely cater for social and cultural needs while those individuals who are politically minded tend to follow the structures set out by the political party of their affiliation and few, if any, resource flows in the reverse direction from the main political parties into the Chinese community.

With these considerations, it is safe to say that no political party has any real or substantial incentive to promote Chinese interests in any manner that the Chinese community desire and which is appropriate, given the mantra of social cohesion.

This is not to say that the main political parties have entirely ignored Chinese interests and needs, but there are significant deficiencies. If the Chinese community therefore desires to have a parliamentary representative from amongst its own people, it must do so with a specially crafted strategy that penetrates deep into the present political structures, capitalises on the strengths of prominent and promising members, and supports with united determination such deserving candidates.

Leadership Academy

The general belief is that there is not so much a dearth of suitable candidates as the apparent lack of interest by Chinese for active involvement in politics. There are eminently sound reasons for the disinterest, and the most common one cited is the inability to make a difference. Economic reasons are important for the Chinese too, as their drive for financial security, prosperity and in many cases professional advancement make investment in time and loss of income difficult to justify in exchange for an uncertain role in politics. Many perceive the time demand to be a negative and unrewarding feature of politics, and prejudices more preferred activities, such as making money, pursuing hobbies and spending time with the family.

To encourage interest in politics amongst the Chinese requires a system of information and participation. These include action group meetings, and it may be necessary to assist with the establishment of local groups due to the dispersal of the Chinese people in Britain. In turn, groups must be networked to maintain liaison and communication for the best outcomes.

Next, we must implement a process of grooming and mentoring by those who are experienced in skills development and management. A cohort of aspirants of all ages and from all walks of life must be built up to avoid a vacuum and to ensure continuity in the flow of politically strong candidates.

A leadership academy to inculcate and promote political awareness and development is therefore proposed. To achieve unimpeachable credibility and universal acceptability, the academy must embrace a mission that gives equal and conjoined emphasis to Chinese communal and wider national interests.

Accessing political structures

Implicit in the effort to gain selection as a parliamentary candidate is the fact that no one in the Chinese community should expect a successful appointment based on any lesser standards than that expected of a candidate from any other racial background. No one owes us a seat, which must be fought. However, it is generally felt that there is a denial of a credibility gap, an unfounded anxiety in trusting the ability of a Chinese to be at least the equal in intellect, commitment and patriotism to an indigenious white candidate.

There are, of course, rare occasions when the inner sanctum of the power brokers in all the main political parties promote a candidate of their choice to the fore, a process known as ‘shoeing in' or parachuting in' of a specially appointed candidate. This move is reserved for stronghold seats and when powerful reasons exist for doing so.

Although the campaign to secure a Chinese MP is broadly non-partisan, it would be preferable that the candidate is from the political party most likely to form the next government.

Achieving political success

The task of the power brokers would be made much easier if the nominated candidate possesses those political qualities and electoral characteristics that are desirable for both the party, the constituents and the country.

Apart from having the necessary qualifications in such matters as integrity, probity and dedication, the candidate must also possess an attractive personality and flair that captivate the public and simultaneously create an empathy that forms the basis of electoral support. Success in a chosen vocation is commendable, but it is no guarantee of desirability, while rounded and broad experience is definitely a very positive attribute. Indeed, a comment that is often heard in denigration of politicians is the narrow range of life skills they possess.

Therefore, a candidate respected by the Chinese community and who displays the qualities favoured by the electorate is the one who should be promoted to contest a safe seat. The ability to draw on the full support of the Chinese community and acceptability of personal traits by the wider public are sine qua non of electoral success for such a candidate.

Supporting candidates

In an age of rapid and pervasive communication, the power of the media is a tool to be deployed for maximum effect to benefit a candidate who has the broadest support of the Chinese community and the political party promoting the candidacy.

 The full range of both the mainstream English and Chinese language media - the newspapers, radio, television and the internet - must be engaged. In turn, the candidate must devote a significant amount of time to achieve a public presence that the media can then feed on.

These efforts require substantial financial and logistical support, and an organised team such as that led by Christine Lee and her colleagues in the BC Project would be ideally placed to coordinate the campaign.  Without concerted fund-raising, the publicity drive will be compromised.

 Finally, the success of any campaign of this nature depends on the close cooperation between the Chinese community-facing team and its counterpart in the political party which the candidate represents.

Conclusion

In Britain and across the world, there are increasing demands for transparency and openness in government. There is also a growing awareness that a modern cohesive society in the United Kingdom can only be realised by a matching change in politics to reflect the diversity of its population.

 As the country enters the preparatory phase for the next General Election, this is arguably the best opportunity for Chinese Britons to support from amongst their ranks worthy members who are willing and able to uphold the pride and honour of the Chinese in Britain by fulfilling their desire for direct parliamentary representation.


Dr Teck K Khong

 
Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
Jeff Minter Posted 20:17 on 29 May 2008
Why spend time and effort on something that will never change?

Whether it's a democracy or a dictatorship, politics consists of talking about everything and doing nothing.
L Posted 21:52 on 29 May 2008
Dear Dr Khong
Thanks for a very good written overview about the representation within the chinese community, I like its rare no-nonsense analysis and its candour of the current situation.

I am of the second generation "BBCs" and have always wanted to debate and discuss such issues but a well set up public infrastructure is not set in place.

It s so easy to be cynical, and to be honest at times I have at odd moments been that way inclined, given the voices, performances and attitudes of some unnamed parties.

I believe most BBCs certainly of my generation are more inclined to support not just chinese communities, and believe things can change for the better for all, if the "right" (small r) person are put in place.
For me communication and discussion with the community is so important if understanding and support is fostered.
If there is a change I like to see right now concerning community matters it is please don't discourage debate, and communicate more, otherwise these matters will dither into nothingness.

Thanks
L
Teck Khong Posted 3:31 on 30 May 2008
Dear Jeff and 'L',

Thank you for your comments.

The best way to understand why we should be at least interested in politics, if not actively involved in it, is really due to the fact that societies all over the world are made up of people living inter-dependently on each other in a whole spectrum of entities such as families, communities, shared interest organisations, work groups, towns, cities and nations.

In all these situations, interactions require frameworks for consistency while continuity and progress depend on dynamic decision processes. That is the basis of politics.

Compared to my peers, my entry into politics is relatively late but importantly, it was triggered simply by the frustrations of a failing system that interfered with the proper conduct of my duties and adherence to the professional ethos observed by all decent doctors and nurses.

Acknowledging that healthcare was my conduit, I discovered another more emotive issue – the matter of ethnicity in society – upon my entry into politics. To greater or lesser extents, we have all encountered prejudice based race, subtle, covert or otherwise, and while we cannot realistically expect to eradicate it, we can nonetheless work to create better mutual understanding so that our lives and livelihoods are not adversely affected by negativity.

That is why I believe we should not and cannot ignore the importance of politics and its influence on our lives. As a community, the Chinese have not been truly ‘in the body of the kirk’, so to speak. I therefore hope my article has stimulated interest and debate as the first step in establishing our due recognition in this society.
Yin - Will it work? Posted 1:41 on 19 June 2008
With the amount of international and foreign events at the moment, even the younger generation of BBC's now are hardly likely to be 'voted in' or be able to participate in any sort of politics. There would be a resent against the 'CCP clone'

Personally, it would be nice to have more chinese voices in politics, it would certainly help the parliamentary system to acknowledge the minorities who are willing to speak up.
P - Chinese MP can't help the Chin Posted 23:39 on 22 June 2008
There are some confusion here. There are 2 ways an ethnic Chinese can be elected an MP in the UK.

1. By Contesting in a constituency where the Chinese has the majority - this will never happen, unless the Chinese in the UK make a conscious effort to populate a geopolitically well defined area. If there are 5 million Chinese in Wales they could declare an autonomous Chinese state of Wales in the UK.

2. By being first and foremost British and second Chinese. This person has to be British born, perhaps third generation, public school educated and has a law degree. He or she would fit seamlessly within the wider population and espouses the wider issues of that population - NOT CHINESE ISSUES. The reality is a Chinese will never be elected an MP defending Chinese rights.

If the number is not on your side make up the deficit with talents. Far more political influence will come from being lawyers, writers, bankers, actors and business tycoons. Forget about being a Chinese MP on the Chinese ticket in the UK.
TK Khong Posted 14:23 on 23 June 2008
P, you are absolutely right on every point; I couldn't agree with you more!
orbital - my experience Posted 0:22 on 16 August 2008
Jeff - too cynical and that's from a cynic! :)

I'm British 1st (and Chinese 2nd? or maybe Chinese not at all!)

I look Chinese - well I was called Chink at school.

I was active in the Ecology Party as it was then in the mid 80s but in the late 90s joined the Lib Dems and got my colleague elected as a local councillor and then we got me elected as a councillor the following year and got more Lib Dems elected in the subsequent 4 years - fantastic to oust an entrenched backward Labour lot!

I suppose I was mildly ambitious and considered wanting to be a PPC somewhere for the Lib Dems but I guess I'm too much of a cynic and I couldn't tolerate those that loved the sound of their own voices and the many a!*#holes councillors.

I was a local councillor for 5 years and I reckon P is correct in that you'll need to be British 1st and Chinese 2nd.

If someone of Chinese ancestry aspires to be an MP just get stuck into a local party, cut your teeth in successful campaigning - perhaps get elected to a local council - get onto the approved list of PPCs. Fight for what you believe in, what you think will help others locally & globally.

If anyone wants advice on successful campaigning...
Kiwinese - Chinese representation in Brit Posted 10:53 on 22 August 2008
In New Zealand there is a Chinese MP, called Pansy Wong. She is not a NZBC, ie. not a Kiwi by birth, and came as a migrant.

The story of her success is due to MMP and working hard to gain strong support from within the Chinese community, and also by participating in the greater community. However,more importantly, she was not held back by any grievances. Baby-boomer NZ-born Chinese, whose families migrated between the late 19th and mid 20th centuries, have been largely held back by historic hostilities that their forebears and even themselves faced growing up in NZ.

Sadly, the "Head down, work hard, don't draw attention to yourself" school of thought still pervades the 'established' part of the Chinese community in New Zealand and other parts of the world. The newer migrants (circa mid 1980's onwards) do not have the same hang-ups.

In my opinion, the key for aspiring politicians of Chinese descent is participation in the community -both within the Chinese community and out in the greater community.

Unless an aspirant can get support in numbers from as many parts of the community, there will not be any recognition and promotion from any political party (not even the BNP!)

A British MP of Chinese descent should not be pipe dream.
Write comment
Name:
Subject:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
Security Code:
Type the code in the image
(helps prevent spam)
Security Image
 
< Prev   Next >