Dimsum masthead
Home arrow Viewpoints arrow Michael Gove: An Idiot Abroad
Michael Gove: An Idiot Abroad PDF Print E-mail
Viewpoints
Friday, 07 January 2011

I am in total despair. Every time Michael Gove opens his mouth, extravagant foolishness and ignorance spews from it.

In a recent Telegraph article, he says:

I was in the Far East last month, to see what I could learn… where I am happy to confess I’d like us to implement a cultural revolution just like the one they’ve had in China. Like Chairman Mao, we’ve embarked on a Long March to reform our education system.

His ignorance of history is baffling and a cause of concern. Where do we get these politicians?The Cultural Revolution was a violent mass revolution resulting in social, political and economic upheaval with over 30 million deaths. Mao singled out his enemies - landlords, rich peasants, intellectuals. In the fight against "class enemies" and "bourgeois reactionaries," teachers, people with a college degree were targeted. Entire schools of elite musicians and teams of athletes were sent to labour camps. Intellectuals were kept in prisons.

In the Cultural Revolution, learning was a crime. The crackdown on teachers, professors and intellectuals was particularly nasty. In secondary schools students humiliated and denounced their teachers. In high schools, teachers wore dunce caps and spent the whole day reciting "I am a demon" in front of classrooms filled with mocking students.

Is this what Gove is advocating?

If this is a case of “metaphorically speaking”, then his analogy is pure contempt for the Chinese in Britain. Many have loss relatives and family during that period in history, and many are just coming to terms with the horrific memories of that period. The frequent usage of Chinese analogies by politicians recently is nothing short of repugnant and gut-wrenching to listen to.

Having spent only a few days in the Far East does not make Gove such an expert on education there. Like Manuel in Fawlty Towers - he knows nothing!!

Yes, teachers and students in Shanghai and Singapore have to be congratulated in coming out tops in a recent leading global study of secondary school performance in maths and science. This is no surprise at all - to really understand why - one needs to look inside a Chinese family.

The pressure on these kids to perform well comes from wthin the family, school and society. Chinese students work extra long hours on school days and continue to have classes on weekends and holidays. These children are victims of a test-oriented education system. Failures in such tests bring shame to themselves and families leading to the high suicide rates amongst them.

Whether it is maths or reading, the more you practice, the better you can get. They are taught to memorise, parrot fashion and regurgitate what they have studied for exams. Any analysis, discursive or exploring other concepts or ideals are alien to their learning processes.

These students fail abysmally at non-standardised tests - open-book; open-notes; Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs); and True/False assessments. Why? Because they do not know how to pass exams that they have not practiced for. Their incapability to apply knowledge acquired in a classroom to real life or non-standardised exams is a cause of concern for many parents and educators.

Students grow up lacking social interaction; interpersonal; teamwork and communicating skills because they have not been allowed to acquire or develop these skills. All their waking hours are spent on memorising and more memorising.

In Singapore, from the strict design of pedagogies and curriculum to the series of standardised examinations, students are moulded into productive units of labour for the future. The introduction of more testing and streaming for younger students is leading to an overheated pressure cooker further damaging their youth and future generation. The recent deaths of two junior college students have once again highlighted the primary ramification from a highly-competitive and rigid education system: tremendous stress and pressure.

Another cost worth considering is the dearth of creativity like research among Singaporean students. The other problem which almost never gets any attention is the complete lack of development of critical thinking skills among Singaporean students. They are unable to read texts critically, offer interpretations, construct good arguments, and communicate clearly.

As a Chinese father, I would not be happy at all in schooling my four year old daughter in Singapore or Shanghai. I wouldn’t want my child to go through the ‘pressure cooker’ educational system where she is taught just to pass exams and incapable of any further comprehension.

We should all take pride in our schools and teachers. Yes, we need to do more to raise standards and expectations in our schools. Yes, we need to encourage our students to take up sciences. Yes, we need to invest more in our children’s future. Yes, we need educators who are motivated and yes, we need a fairer system where children have access to good schools in their communities.

To all educators, teachers, head teachers and governors out there, do not allow Michael Gove any where near your school. Stop this dangerous political vandalism in our school and education system before we start counting the number of suicides amongst our children.

by Sonny Leong, Publisher and Chair, Chinese for Labour.

 
Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
Neville Patterson - What point are you really maki Posted 13:22 on 10 January 2011
You start with an interpretation of what someone said, describe something quite unrelated and then denounce that someone based upon your interpretation.

Will your next post show that two plus two equals five?
Madam Miaow - Gove Posted 1:05 on 11 January 2011
Gove is increasingly proving himself to be incompetent when he was built up as some sort of genius before this coalition — which we didn't vote for — achieved power with the help of the LibDems. And who can forget what their promises were?

Sonny, among many others, is right to point out the vandalism being done to our education system. The statement by Gove in the Telegraph is indeed bizarre.

There's such a huge growing concern regarding this government's actions that we need an urgent serious debate. I'm puzzled as to why Neville can't engage with the points being made and has to be so personal instead.
Neville Patterson - Opinion or fact? Posted 8:12 on 11 January 2011
quote: "I'm puzzled as to why Neville can't engage with the points being made and has to be so personal instead."

1) It was not personal.
2) The reasoning followed in the original post was SEVERELY floored.
3) The original post was political opinion. It is NOT fact.

Quote: Sonny, among many others, is right to point out the vandalism being done to our education system.

This is again an opinion. It is NOT fact.
Madam Miaow - Gove's Cultural Revolutio Posted 12:36 on 11 January 2011
"I was in the Far East last month, to see what I could learn… where I am happy to confess I’d like us to implement a cultural revolution just like the one they’ve had in China. Like Chairman Mao, we’ve embarked on a Long March to reform our education system."

This quote is self-evidently barking. Sonny is far from being the only one to be alarmed by Gove's pronunciations and actions in power.
Neville Patterson - Guffaw Posted 8:31 on 13 January 2011
Quote: "Sonny is far from being the only one to be alarmed by Gove's pronunciations ..."

What a classic (and revealing) piece of prejudicial nonsense.
Zhao - a common problem Posted 14:15 on 13 January 2011
One thing I find very common among many of the Whiteman is that they have such a sense of superiority that most of them are very happy to talk to (or lecture) the Yellowman or the Blackman or indeed fellow Whiteman about anything, even things which they the Whiteman have very little real knowledge about.
Apolitical & Non-Aligned - Another Labour Prejudice Posted 2:29 on 24 January 2011
Sonny's article reminded me of a very famous and important Labour Cabinet member who once said. Quote ' What can we learn from a Coolie economy' implying that descendants of Coolies in Singapore are 'inferior' to the western counterparts in UK. This was before Blair became Prime Minister. It looked like the Labour Party still keeps its head in the Sand. ???An Ostrich attitude ??? with regards to its former colonies????

Of course, Sonny had not done or had conveniently forgotten that the education system in Singapore and Malaysia were implemented by educators from UK, the most prominent of them being Tunku Abdul Rahman and Premier Lee Kuan Yu.

I was educated in the Far East in a former Anglican Church School and my education was certainly not by 'Rote'.

Another important point that Sonny had not factored into his article is that the Chinese person is one of the most adaptable in the human species. This comes from the ability to take on hardship whetever and whenever. This had an influence in the success of the Chinese even in the UK educational system whether the Chinese student comes from; whether British born, American born, Canadian born, Australian born, Hong Kong born, Malaysian born, or Singapore born, etc.

Gove's ignorance equals Sonny's prejudiced political outburst. No real research or 'open mind' being illustrated by both party.
MELLOYELLOFELLO - Simple courteousies Posted 12:09 on 2 April 2011
F**K OFF Michael Gove!!
Do I tell you how to make love to your wife? Point is there is a demarc of what constitutes as ..your opinion and what doesn't belong..peace-making all over the world BS!!More like "Piece"making divide and conquer!!
Your backyard is falling apart and people are becoming and unsettled and nervous,due to reforms.Instead of going on a free holiday on the tax-payers expense - research and do your job properly and generate some money and create some results for the country instead on winging-it ..Bullshit B**TH!!no apologies.
Only registered users can write comments!