Dimsum masthead
Home arrow Viewpoints arrow The girls who want to have it all - by Twenty-First Century Girl Suzie Wong
The girls who want to have it all - by Twenty-First Century Girl Suzie Wong PDF Print E-mail
Viewpoints
Wednesday, 09 September 2009

Sample ImageAn excited nervousness hangs in the air as a horde of girls team the corridors of the Novotel in St Pancras, giggling to each other and making final make-up touch-ups before they go to meet the judges. The sixty contestants have travelled from across the country in a bid to win the chance of becoming the next Miss China UK 2009.

Of the sixty only twenty will be selected to go through to the next round, to be only further whittled down to the last remaining twelve. These will then appear on stage in the grand final at the Apollo Theatre in London on the 18th October, the results of which will go on to be broadcast across Asia and Europe.

For each of the girls this could be the next step to potential stardom. For Miss China Europe 2007 winner Oceana Zhu, her career has gone from strength to strength, after signing a management contract with TVB Hong Kong. Her foray into acting has seen Zhu landing a major role in the movie ‘Prince of Tears’ directed by famous Chinese director Yon Fan. From drama student to walking the red carpet at this year’s Venice Film Festival, Zhu has been catapulted into the limelight in the space of two years. Her success is something most girls dream about; when you consider the media exposure and endorsement possibilities - the rewards can be incredibly lucrative.

The girls’ backgrounds range from bankers, accountants, medical students to schoolgirls still at sixth form. They have come from across the country, some even as far as Ireland, in a bid for fame and fortune. A friendly camaraderie is evident; there is no bitchy rivalry yet, more of a supportive sister-hood. I have yet to witness any tears or tantrums or gossipy cliques; rather I am impressed by their grace and maturity.

THE THREE STAGES

Sample ImageEach girl will be required to go through three stages and will be judged accordingly on each: the Catwalk, the Photoshoot and the Interview. Each round will have its own panel of judges who will give each girl a score according to how well she performs. The most nail biting part is the interview round where the girls will find themselves face to face with the executive judges and answer a barrage of questions. Here they will have a chance to tilt the balance if they have not performed so well in the other rounds. The top twenty that score the highest will go through to the next round.

WALKING THE WALK

I sneak into the catwalk judging room and watch as the girls attempt to impress the judges with their moves. It’s one of the more awkward elements of the contest as very few of them will have had any catwalk experience before. The majority totter in high heels and criss-cross the rooms dressed in bikinis. Judge Fiona Hoang, explains that whilst catwalk experience is not expected, they are looking for a degree of poise and presentation. ‘We watch the girls for confidence, posture and how they present themselves. Height is important however – we will be looking for girls over 5ft 3, any shorter and they won’t come across well on the stage.’ The girls today come in all shapes and sizes ranging from short to tall, curvy to slim although no one here today seems to be over a size 12.

I watch Maggie Chan, a Hong Kong-born twenty-three year old student totter precariously in high heels in front of the judges. Currently studying for a chartered accountancy degree at Ulster University, Chan has flown in especially from Belfast for the competition. Having lived the past six years in Ireland she chatters sweetly with a fetching Irish lilt and confesses to being nervous in what is her first beauty contest.

Sample ImageFor some of other contestants this won't be their first time at a beauty pageant. For Christina Gee it is her third such contest and the ease at which she goes through her paces demonstrates a confidence borne of experience. Currently working as a financial analyst at Deutsche Bank, Gee looks more like a fresh faced teen straight out of school belying her twenty-five years. Standing at 167 cm tall she is very slim, like most of the girls here. I ask her what her secret is. She laughs and declares she doesn’t diet. ‘But I don’t eat much English food’ she confesses. ‘I prefer Asian food, Chinese, Thai or Japanese.’ I ask her if she eats bread or potatoes. ‘No bread, but potatoes yes.’ Maybe this could be the key to maintaining a slim figure - I make a mental note to myself, more rice and less bread. This could be my new daily mantra. Gee sees the pageant as a good opportunity to diversify into charity work, miles away from the unrelenting pace of banking. Armed with a degree in mathematics, Tianjin-born Gee shows that brains and beauty are the rule not the exception amongst today’s entrants.

Some of the girls here range from the quietly ambitious to the more openly driven. Twenty-five year old Tuyet Ho, a project manager at Deutsche Bank sits firmly in the latter camp. ‘I am here because I definitely want to win. I am very competitive, self-motivated and independent.’ In fact she uses the word competitive three times to describe herself and I am struck by her honesty and openness. For in spite of her personal assertion, the competitive, desperate air that so typically hangs in beauty contests is strangely lacking today. A competitive rivalry must exist but if it does it lies much subdued. The resounding feedback from the girls today is primarily how pleased they are to have made so many new friends. A faux humility for the camera? I would say not, the atmosphere seems to be genuinely friendly and warm. Comfortable in their own skin and assured of their talents, the girls remain polite, composed and respectful throughout. Whether that will be the case in the final round is another story.

Sample ImageINTERVIEW ROUND

The photography round is straightforward enough as the girls hold various poses for the camera but it’s the interview with the judges which proves to be the real clincher. The girls have just a few minutes to impress the judges and let their personality and wit shine through. The interview panel is made up of three executive judges, the same judges that will eventually pick the final pageant winner; Daniel Chan sits in the middle, responsible for creating the concept of MCUK and showcasing it in Europe. On his right is Wendy Wang, China Desk Manager of sponsor CMC Markets and to the left sits TV presenter Cecilia Chew, from the network broadcaster-giant TVB-S.

The first candidate to be interviewed is twenty-four year old Tina Sun. Originally from Dandong in China the 5ft 9" beauty could easily pass for a catwalk model. However she herself admits that height alone is not enough. ‘A lot of the girls here have some kind of talent, some are musicians or dancers. I think you need a special talent to stand out’

SIFTING THE WHEAT FROM THE CHAFF

In this overwhelming sea of beauty it is the judges’ difficult task to pick out who should go through to the next round. I ask them what it is they are looking for. Wendy Wang declares it is definitely brains over beauty. “It is not particularly what they say but how they present themselves and respond. There are no right answers but we are looking for someone who is confident and can think on their feet - if they have experience performing on stage then that will help too. ”

Each girl has her own unique selling points and is given ten minutes in the interview room to impress the judges. Some girls shine more brightly than others leaving the weaker contestants apparent. One British-born candidate, on being asked to state her reasons for entering the competition, responded that she saw it as a way of reclaiming her Asian heritage and a way of making her parents proud. The judges smile politely but their silence is telling after she leaves the room. The crown for Miss China UK does not automatically confer to its owner a degree of culture by proxy.

Sample ImageSome of the other contestants have more clearly defined goals as to what they are trying to achieve. Jenny Hao, a twenty-two year old medical student at Imperial College, is clear about her personal and professional direction, pageant or no pageant. Amongst one of the taller girls here at 5ft’ 7” the Shenyang-born student decided she wanted to practise medicine at the age of sixteen. ‘I would like to be a doctor or a surgeon. If I won the competition I would use the publicity and media to highlight charity work in China, especially in the poor rural areas where people cannot afford to pay for medicine.’ She remarks how one of the greatest features in the UK is the National Health Service. ‘It’s a free service that we are very lucky to have over here and take for granted. In China healthcare must be paid for and many poor people cannot afford it.’

Another entrant who impresses the judges with her focus and determination is nineteen year old Gisele Lee. Having previously appeared on X-factor, nineteen-year old Lee talks passionately about her music and bursts into song in front of the judges with a heartfelt rendition of Mariah Carey’s ‘I will make it through the rain.’ Her voice wavers towards the end but her conviction and sincerity shines through. The judges look genuinely impressed and give her a round of applause and Lee’s face flushes with delight.

TALKING THE TALK

Although not officially stated the contestants are required to be proficiently bi-lingual. The judges grill the girls in Mandarin, Cantonese or English or sometimes combination of all three. It quickly becomes clear that those that do not speak either of the Chinese languages are at a significant disadvantage as the filmed finals will be conducted mainly in Mandarin and Cantonese. Broadcast to an Asian audience there will be very little English spoken on stage. Production house TVB have created a show to target the home and overseas Asian market and bilingualism is to be expected. This could prove to be the last tricky hurdle for some of the less fluent British-born contestants.

THE ICING ON THE CAKE

So what exactly is driving such qualified and intelligent young ladies to enter a beauty pageant in the first place? Do they in any way mind that they are subjecting themselves to such a blatant objectification of their bodies? Or do they see it as just the icing on the cake on top of a long list of achievements? Already armed with a bright future in terms of career and qualifications these girls seem eager to prove themselves equally in the beauty arena and are not ashamed to admit it.

THE PURSUIT OF BEAUTY

The fact that there is considerably less of a stigma attached to beauty pageants in China than here in the west is telling. The beauty pageant’s newfound rise in popularity can be better understood by examining it against China’s historical socio-cultural backdrop in the decades that preceded it.

For a start it is a relatively new phenomenon. China’s first beauty contest appeared in Guangzhou in 1988, a good sixty years behind America’s first national pageant in 1921, and thirty years after the UK’s first beauty contest Miss World in 1951 (which still runs to this present day). Beauty contests had been banned by Mao ever since he established rule in 1949 with the Communist Party. At the height of the Mao-era, the ‘60s for Chinese women were harsh repressive times. Whilst their western sisters in the United States and the UK were going through a sexual revolution known as the Swinging Sixties, openly proclaiming free love and publicly torching their bras, the women of China were undergoing the equivalent of the Suppressive Sixties, denouncing their femininity for entirely different reasons.

In the name of Maoist sexual equality women cropped their hair short and donned the same drab uniforms as their male cadres. The Cultural Revolution of 1966-1977, on paper was designed to destroy social distinction. In reality however it only served to deprive women of their personal freedoms and the right to govern their own bodies.

Quite simply the feminist argument against beauty pageants is one that has not raised its head in China yet purely because China has yet to experience a fully emancipated, liberal society. Feminist derision is a luxury that Chinese women have yet to experience, more concerned with getting ahead in today’s society. Fast forward to the present day and it is as almost if Chinese women are going through a reversed feminist movement, keen to show off their looks to the world and are now given social sanction to do so.

It is also striking testimony that most of today’s contestants are here due to their mothers’ encouragement. Tracy Ng, an eighteen year old sixth-form student has come down from Liverpool due to her mum’s insistence that she put herself forward. ‘It was my mum who told me about the competition and she’s the main reason I’m here today.’ Could it be that the pageant’s strongest supporters hail from a generation of women who, unable to celebrate their own beauty, are now actively encouraging their daughters to go forth and celebrate theirs?

The Chinese culture has traditionally prized education above the ‘shallow exterior.’ Yet there is nothing to say that both cannot be had. Shallowness may be frowned upon, but money, travel and career possibilities can give what was dismissed as superficial, the new thumbs up. You will find girls pushing themselves onto the world stage keen to enjoy what other countries have enjoyed for decades before them. Looks can only be an aid not a hindrance in this media-driven age. The times they are indeed a-changing.

For today’s generation of Chinese women the opportunity to forge an identity outside the traditional role of sacrificial mother/dutiful wife is very real and obtainable. The path to independence and success is littered with stepping stones of which a beauty contest is only one. The opening up of China’s economy has made a big difference to how contests such as these are received. What once was derided is in today’s Asia a practical and plausible route to riches. The global licensing opportunities mean TV broadcasters are onto a lucrative money-spinner beaming their content to an Asian community across the world. It’s a win-win situation for everyone.

Sample ImageTHE GIRLS WHO WANT TO HAVE IT ALL

And what about the girls who want it all? The majority of today’s contestants come across as high-flying achievers. A PHD from Oxford and the accolade of beauty queen seem to go hand in hand these days. No longer thought of (if you’ll forgive the pun), as the crowning glory of a girl’s career, the title of beauty queen is just another notch to an already heavily scored bow. The beauties I witness today already have a firm idea of where they are going, and are savvy enough to use any means to get them there. Charity work in the medical field on top of juggling a family and career? I call it the Angelina Jolie effect – the girls who want it all and aren’t afraid to say so.

This email address is being protected from spam bots, you need Javascript enabled to view it

See the Miss China UK contestants here

 
Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
pensggs - A piece of good reporting Posted 0:20 on 10 September 2009
A well written piece, written from a female prespective.

Today's Chinese girls whether British born or otherwise, no longer have to sell their soul, to be successful.

The battle was fought and built by their forebearers like Anna May Wong, and the road ahead is paved with opportunities. The only missing ingredient to making the most of these opportunities is the guts and self confidence to grasp them with both hands.
Jenny Hao - Very interesting Posted 2:01 on 10 September 2009
A very well written piece and really interesting to see an overview and impression of the whole experience.
Rose - Beauty and brains Posted 8:40 on 10 September 2009
Excellent coverage, and social commentary.

Oriental girls have high aspirations, we're not just a pretty face!
Ali - Excellent coverage Posted 11:59 on 10 September 2009
Excellent description of the day and I can almost feel the atmosphere in there. A good background research and physcologic observation is evident. Very well written.

I am very much impressed with the high aspirations of these girls.. I just wonder, after winning this what next for them? World domination?!
Gisela Lee - Impressive Posted 20:35 on 10 September 2009
A compelling and intriguing article capturing the event's aura sensationally.
Tan Posted 20:28 on 11 September 2009
Enjoy reading this article, but also what it omits.
Zofia Magrian - Very good insight Posted 17:42 on 12 September 2009
A very good insight not only into the course of the beauty competition itself but also into the types of candidates and what a description of a modern high-flying Chinese woman would look like. Plus historical background and social analysis.

Thumbs up, keep up the good work!
Wendy Wang - Very impressive well done Suzi Posted 14:11 on 15 September 2009
Hi Suzie

Just read your article, very impressed,well done. A great piece of work, keep it up:)
JBH - interesting article! Posted 14:32 on 16 September 2009
enjoyed reading it - maybe a few more pictures would be nice (or is that sexist?)
Dogface Posted 16:43 on 19 September 2009
Here here where are the pictures? How am supposed to know anything about the beautiful contestants and make a vote.
Adee Posted 17:31 on 21 September 2009
Maybe we should have a Mr China UK too? Just to make it fair :)
Jackie - ramble Posted 20:24 on 21 September 2009
I think it takes alot of front to enter these contests and deal with the consequences if it doesn't go as well. It is only enpowering if you win or get the money making contracts afterwards. Is it the lure of fame and celebrity like many of the reality shows. And what about feminism not in China which is behind, but overseas educated Chinese? Most high achievers do not pursue these contest, that s not to say they are wrong, however they make work behind the scenes where the real prize is.
prvs contestant - why I entered Posted 15:23 on 23 September 2009
You only live once, and your life is what you make of it. It's easy to criticise - and previously, I would have stayed away too and never even gave pageants a thought. But with age comes wisdom and yearning for new experiences.

I'm glad I made the choice to apply, otherwise I would have lived the rest of my life wondering what it would have been like if I did this (amongst many other things, as I believe in trying everything once)... Also when im old and wrinkly I would appreciate having made the MOST of my youth much more! ;)

We grow through life experiences, not by reading books. The real prize is self discovery and self awareness, a quality that can take you very far in life. Personally entering the pageant has made me assess what I value in my life and what direction I should be heading in, what makes me myself, and most importantly, to be more open and alert for any other new experiences that can enrich my life.
Anonymous - comments Posted 21:50 on 23 September 2009
If you are the bookish type then books are everthing because it is the most powerful medium that documents "life experiences" that one is unable to experience entirely in ones limited lifespan.
We all have our unique ways of enriching life, if you come, for example a low working class takeaway background then opportunities have to fought for hard, if you want to test or use your body as a commodity that's your free choice, leaving the feminist debate aside. Even Sarah Palin was an ex-beauty pageant it is not entirely unfeasible that she could be the next president. Then there are also very able people who fight for women rights like the recent student protests. It not about books but a passion for equality and allowing fair debate and making your voice heard.
Petra - BBC? Posted 19:25 on 25 September 2009
So how many of the girls in the top 12 are British Born Chinese?

Hmmmmm..... most of them seem to be students from China. Is that because they are fluent in Mandarin and Cantonese?
Size 16 - and the winner is... Posted 20:35 on 28 September 2009
What does the UK represent in this competition where is the British UK part of the equation?
I have nothing against students from China or anywhere else. I just think the concept of beauty needs to be challenged more. Why isn't? Beauty is not a fixed ideal if so the winner will have bound feet.
Clem Posted 1:05 on 7 October 2009
An excellent article and well written. I was deeply saddened to read about the Chinese women not being able to express their femininity, absolutely heart wrenching.
laura Posted 0:20 on 9 October 2009
good article i must agree with the comment by petra as to how many girls are british born chinese? for this competition to be fair i think it should be won by a british born chinese.
mike Posted 0:06 on 18 October 2009
Well, it is quite clear from the title Miss China UK , which means Miss from China living in UK . You BBC, ABC, NBC...?BC have no chance to win.
Olhos de Gato - pffft Posted 13:21 on 2 November 2009
You're both wrong Laura and Mike. The title of the pagaent specifies Huayui - those with Chinese blood.

This should rightfully include ALL Chinese sisters in the UK, whether they have been here 5 generations or 5 years. I believe this is good for the unity of us as a community, who still all the time too readily dismiss each other as not Chinese enough, not British enough, being the wrong kind of Chinese, eating the wrong food, having the wrong friends, liking the wrong music etc

I'm still not big on beauty contests, but I do think having a winner from Fujian says a lot about what we are like as a community now.

The complaint that the competition is stacked against the BBC is not completely valid, since all the CBC girls had to speak English (no doubt painfully learnt over many years) to a very good degree too.
Katy - Interesting. Posted 23:56 on 6 November 2009
Hi all, It's right to say that beauty rules all if you have the looks? I liked looking at beautiful women but yet I have not seen any beautiful Chinese girl in the UK? Through the all the pageant started from 2006 till 2009 I yet waiting to see if a contestant from UK to win the next Miss Chinese International. So is it fair to say that to promote Chinese Cultural to the community is from the winner but I don't seem to see much of that after they have won. So what about the people who works behind the background do they get paid to do this job or are they just wanted to promote Chinese Cultural to the world? So I just wondered what about the people who are not beautiful, do they get a chance to promote this as-well and to show off their femininity or their intellectual ability? If the beauty pageant is only their to promote Cultural aspect for the community so why do you need to pay for the ticket to see the pageant and why can't it be free to all for those who is interested? I just think is all to do with the lubricative business
and is nothing to do with beauty or promoting the cultural aspect for women as mentioned in the Article. Beside I would not pay £15-30 just to see the pageant it's just a waste of time and money there are nothing meaningful about going to see a pageant show, well maybe for men but I rather go to a fashion show for which I can see better looking girls and designer clothes all at once.
Anonymous Posted 5:27 on 24 November 2009
olhos de gato you are a moron. The odds are stack against the BBC's to start with. I'll tell you why. The CBC's in that contest, i dont mean the chaff, I mean those who made it through to the end were almost all the extremely well educated bourgeois types, who have very privileged backgrounds back in China etc. They go to the best schools and recive the best education. They're not some poverty stricken chaff hiding in a boat from fujian. They've studied English to such a high level that they can study a degree in subjects like medicine all in English. These courses are extremely expensive for foreign students, only the wealthy can afford it. Do you really think a BBC is capable of going to go to a university in China or hongkong to study medicine in their second language of cantonese or mandarin? They can't. So the CBC's have a huge advantage. Also, many BBC's have regional british accents which are quite vulgar sounding on the ear, whereas CBC's try and speak eloquently, they are a completely different class. The majority of BBC's go to local state funded schools, whereas the CBC's went to the best schools in China etc. There is no comparison.

The contest is basically open to anyone who is chinese who is in the UK at the time. These foreign chinese students are not even citizens of this country, they dont have citizenship, only temporary student visa, they should not be allowed to enter.

The BBC's are not chinese enough to win the contest, the contest discriminates against them. Their command of their 2nd language cantonese/mandarin...will always be poorer in standard when compared with an CBC speaking their 2nd language English. There is no chinese language on the curriculum in the UK, which basically means learning it from their parents or going to sunday school which not all parents send their kids to. And large numbers of parents of BBC's in the UK have quite low literacy education levels, theyre from rural areas of new territories etc, many of whom speak hakka etc and their command of cantonese is very poor standard and have unpleasant accents.

The author using phrases such as "western sisters" ??? what are you? some kind of chinese feminist dyke? Only they would use phrases like that.
dumbass Posted 0:10 on 7 December 2009
anonymous you are a dickhead go and preach somewhere else. olhos de gato is your intellectual superior as is suzie wong - go and do everyone a favour and flush your head down a toilet
MrB - Racial purity Posted 8:21 on 8 December 2009
How do they decide if you are Chinese enough?
If one of your grandparents is the wrong race do they disqualify you?

You can only find white people writings things as racist as some of the commenters here on the BNP website.

Olhos de Gato, people like you want it both ways, to be treated as if you belong in the UK the same as native British, but you want to join together with people purely because of your ethnic group.
----------------------------------


Also enjoyed: "Although not officially stated the contestants are required to be proficiently bi-lingual. The judges grill the girls in Mandarin, Cantonese or English."

That would be trilingual.

You also say "The Chinese culture has traditionally prized education above the ‘shallow exterior.’"

For women? Are you sure? Do you know anything about the status of women in China before the 20th century?
Miss China Uk discriminatory Posted 5:44 on 21 December 2009
Its very difficult to tell, but I dont think there were any bbc's in the final short list, maybe one or two at most. The reason I say its difficult to tell is because the official website of the miss china uk has deliberately left the each candidates place of birth BLANK.

Its obvious, that as the title says, its nothing more than a contest to see find a VERY VERY VERY FOBBY chinese winner suitable for the media career in the east asian market in the far east. Thats basically all the contest is, it has absolutely nothing to do with being british, except a piece of paper which says that you're a british subject, but of course these contestants are anything but british. They're only in the UK for parasitic reasons, they always have their eye on their homeland which is china.

I read that one girl for example, when asked about her food preferences (obviously to test how "chinese" the contestants are) she replied...that she hardly ever ate potatoes and never eaten bread. I mean are you seriously telling me that someone who is british doesn't eat bread or potatoes? Only foreigners or extreme religious types dont eat those types of 'western' food, they're basically FOB's fresh off the boat's from China. I think there was only one malay chinese girl in the shortlist, I mean what chance is she going to have with her accent and dark skin and not being a mainlander?

Another finalist who I won't name...said in her blog...that her rich daddy using his gold card membership bought her a first class ticket for a flight to china to return to the motherland...i.e where she was born. There is absolutely no way you can call these girls british. The only thing british about them is a passport which says they're a citizen of the UK, other than that, they are basically foreigners.

i completely agree with mike's Posted 0:06 on 18 October 2009

"Well, it is quite clear from the title Miss China UK , which means Miss from China living in UK . You BBC, ABC, NBC...?BC have no chance to win."
The Truth Posted 19:21 on 24 December 2009
Its true.

The pageant SHOULD be British born girls entering the competition only, i totally agree.

And from knowing one of the contestants in the final 12, only 4 were actually BBC's. The rest were born else where.

The winner of Miss China UK didnt even speak english! Surely that defeats the whole competition? She wasn't representing UK, she was just representing China.
Oh dear Posted 23:09 on 3 January 2010
How pathetic to have non-British born Chinese as the main (only) competitors. Indeed what's up with the title? Miss China UK? Isn't that an oxymoron in itself, placing two countries side by side? Miss Chinese UK would be more apt, as it indicates an ethnic Chinese who is British.... not someone born in China, raised in China and just came over here to study. That would be Miss China.
Only registered users can write comments!