Home arrow Viewpoints arrow Why our Identities Mean a lot to us as BBCs
Why our Identities Mean a lot to us as BBCs PDF Print E-mail
Viewpoints
Wednesday, 13 February 2008

Let’s face it: as British born Chinese, people of other ethnic backgrounds cannot help but ask us where we come from. I get asked that question numerous times in my life and tell them that I am Chinese but was born and raised in London in the UK. Being a BBC meant I had to go through life with two cultural identities: one being British and the other as Chinese. It’s the same thing with ABC’s (American born), AUBC (Australian born) and other Chinese Diaspora communities. We Chinese may have the same skin colour, our eyes may be similar but what differentiates us BBCs with ABCs etc is our accents. Additionally, A BBC speaking with say a Brummie or Glaswegian accent is no different to a Caucasian, white Brummie or Scot. And so whilst, technically our race is different, the accents will be of similar vein.

Diaspora is a somewhat complex term mainly derided from race and cultural studies, that refers to people of a particular racial background, whose ethnic and cultural roots and upbringing are stemmed in a) awareness and the sense of belonging, b) discovering, learning and understanding your identity and c) acknowledging what it is to be a Chinese person living and residing within a non- Chinese society. These types of questions are part of what is known as the ‘identity crisis’ that certain Chinese Brits are faced with, during at some point of their lives. Many of them are unsure about what makes a BBC a BBC, as well as being uncertain as to what they have to offer to society, in terms of skills and abilities and how their achievements say something about their British Chinese identity. But this, in itself, poses a challenge which many of them face because whereas on one hand you are learning about your cultural identity, in regards to your nationality, race and accent, on the other you are also having to deal with all manners of racist and discriminatory behaviour from other people.  

Cultural studies expert Stuart Hall argues in his essay: ‘Cultural Identity and Diaspora’ that we have two identities: the first as in ‘being’ - offering a sense of unity and commonality towards our country of birth or residency and the second being the ‘becoming’ - i.e. the process of identifying ourselves with those particular cultures that we have within and around ourselves. Another point which he makes is that cultural identities are subject to a) history, b) culture and c) wealth and power. Therefore, the Chinese identity is often tied to things such as being hardworking, nerdy, as well as timid and non-expressive; thus it is often linked to the argument about stereotypes.

Being British of Chinese descent, I feel that our identities as portrayed in the media go way beyond that of the Jackie Chan’s, Jet Li’s, not to mention that the so-called perceptions of members of our ethnic community as DVD sellers, takeaway workers, of non-Chinese actors speaking broken English and mimicking the way we talk is old fashioned and tedious. I feel that we have so much to offer, through educating other cultures about our culture and educating future generations of BBCs. We have the potential to do well and excel in fields that people don’t normally associate us with - it just takes hard work, determination, commitment and self-belief. All we read, see and hear in the Western media is of Chinese people from China and Hong Kong, particularly in a negative light- but never about the achievements of Chinese Brits, and even Chinese Americans - unless you’re named Lucy Liu -, Canadians, Australians and so forth. Frankly, I find this repetitive and to an extent, somewhat tiresome as well.

Last Sunday’s Chinese New Year celebrations in Central London however weren’t by any means great. Like most of London’s Chinese community, I was disappointed by the turn out and the way it had unfolded; I pictured the day to be special, that there will be lion and dragon dances on show, that the atmosphere in Chinatown will be buzzing and millions of people will flock into the area. Instead, all the main cultural events were situated in Trafalgar square and there were only a few stalls being set up selling cakes, jewellery and decorations in Chinatown; it was too quiet, Chinatown? More like a ghost town. And yet what a difference Chinese New Year makes in America, Australia and Canada: the crowds were buzzing, the bright Red and Gold was an illuminating sight to behold. The street parades were exciting and reminiscent of the Notting Hill carnival here in London. Why cannot we put on a good show like they have done?

They certainly put ours to shame. The New Year celebrations are memorable to so many Chinese people around the world, not just throughout China, Hong Kong - it isn’t just a celebration of our culture, but it is stark reminder of our roots and status as members of that community and to showcase to other ethnic minority groups our role within a multi-cultural society, such as Britain.

Too often we are accused of being too ‘passive’ and submissive, of not doing enough to further enhance our image in an attempt to challenge those perpetuating stereotypes, as instead we prefer to sit back and do ‘nothing’. The fear of speaking out, thus often implying intimidation, fear and lack of self-confidence within ourselves, as well as worrying about its consequences has to be thoroughly addressed and looked into. This is not what I call arrogance but confidence. Do we want to remain anonymous and be perceived as being ‘invisible’ throughout the rest of society, so that the UK mainstream media for instance can continue televising Chinese people and mocking our culture - or do we want others to take notice and appreciate us for our efforts, our talents and to give our community something to be proud of? Assimilation - not dissemination is crucial. 

Being BBCs, we have to face and overcome so many struggles, hurdles, as well as challenges, but it is also crucial that our identities as Chinese Brits remain firmly rooted and that they act as a motivator to help inspire ourselves and other BBCs to achieve their own, as well as our own goals in life-whatever they may be, in whatever field it may be and to give them and us hope and inspiration for the future.

 Do you share Waiching Liu's views? Share you thoughts below.

 
Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
Susan S. Cheung - BBCs can't be apathetic Posted 20:12 on 14 February 2008
Dear Waiching Liu,

Thank you for adding some interesting points to the issue of identity for BBCs. I agree that we go through what is known as "identity crisis" at some point or another in our lives, usually as we are growing up. I wrote about identity in an earlier DimSum article: http://www.dimsum.co.uk/features/bbc-or-abc---its-all-about-identity.html

I think many BBCs just want to blend into mainstream society (and we do that well) and don't want to be the spokesperson for our cultural roots/ancestry. Many also don't see themselves as role models for other BBCs and they don't want to draw light upon themselves. I have written in depth about BBC role models (see the Features section).

We are a tiny minority in the UK and, therefore, each of our voices DO count because who best can tell the stories of the British-Born Chinese experience and our unique perspectives, rather than have stereotypes forced upon us by mainstream media.

I think as our parents' generations were the pioneers paving the way for us, our generation(s) must be the advance party making inroads (no matter how small) in how people in society perceive us and our achievements. We have the education and we should have the will to be seen and heard (and this is not about being big-headed or taking credit for something we didn't do). We have unique experiences because of our backgrounds and often or not we are good in our jobs/fields. So instead of not being bothered, why not go for those awards at work, write articles for your company magazine, community newsletter or local newspaper, write the screenplay or story and submit it for the competition, be interviewed at Chinese New Year and other times, volunteer to do higher profile projects at work, talk to friends and the community you live in about being a BBC and what that means, volunteer for the Parent Teacher's Association or church committee or local community action group or volunteer to help a certain group of people in your community, such as the seniors or children - in other words be seen and heard. You don't have to write about the British Chinese experience per se, but acknowledging your roots through being a community person or being excellent in your role at work or in a hobby will go a long way to show BBCs in a good, interesting and diverse light.

The more I see BBCs' apathy (it still all about survival somehow) the more I feel we need to stand up, but sometimes I fear my voice is in the minority even within my own minority!

Best Regards,

Susan S. Cheung
Waiching Liu - RE: BBC's can't be apathetic Posted 16:07 on 15 February 2008
Dear Susan,

Thank you for taking the time to post a response to my discussion on this particular topic. i appreciate a lot. I just want to raise some interesting points that you have brought up on here. okay, the first being BBCs wanting to be part of british mainstream society but who prefer to take a back seat; well, on one hand you may be right, but when its comes to media representations on tv, it is in contrast rather woeful. Why is it that in the media, blacks, whites and asians are discussed and featured on tv shows, magazines here in britain but yet there are no chinese faces to speak of?

Back when I was at college and university, I opted to study Media Studies because I wanted to learn more about the subject from a practical and theoretical perspective. It was interesting because not only did I cover film, tv etc but also being the only chinese student meant i had to bring in discussions about my experiences and perceptions of the media and the lack of representations of chinese within mainstream media, especially tv itself.

I definitely believe that the media has a role to play in educating and informing society as a whole about other minority groups, of whom are disadvantaged from certain sectors of contemporary establishments such as the media. Chinese people exist everywhere you look and in almost every country.

Unlike the UK, there are ABCs in australia and america, applying their trade within arts and entertainment. Names such as Jeff Fatt, Kylie Kwong and Vera Wang, Kelly Hu, James Hong and Lucy Liu are well known in their respective countries. Which relates to your previous article on rolemodels, of which we seem to lack here in UK.

In truth, intelligence counts for nothing if you don't take opportunities that are made available for you, or even risks. A chinese Brit may be one of the brightest minds, but if he/she cannot see what is in front of them and make the most of that experience, then what use is their intelligence and knowledge to anyone, or to themselves?

I have already written and posted an article on the lack of media representations of chinese people here on this site and I am going to write and submit my entry for the BBC bites british born chinese experience competition, as well as undertake media-related voluntary work later this month. And so hopefully, these experiences will lead to something big afterwards. We are the smallest ethnic group in the whole of Britain but as i mentioned we have so much to contribute to society and for other communities to learn from us as well.

Waiching
Susan S. Cheung Posted 20:53 on 15 February 2008
Dear Waiching Liu,

Further to your comments, you speak about those of Chinese descent in other countries. As someone who now lives in the USA, I can say there are more American-born Chinese here than BBCs in the UK and, therefore, as communities are further along in generations, people have been able to get into mainstream organizations and professions and, therefore, you see more Chinese/Asian faces in the media and other public forums.

In the UK, we are still a "young" minority with small numbers and, thus, the onus is on people like yourself who are breaking into certain professions like the media to be the pioneers and brave ones to forge paths for future generations.

In my career as a training and development specialist and management consultant, I broke the stereotype many times that Chinese women are passive demure types who are quiet and rarely speak. I was often training first-line supervisors, many white and male. In the late 1980s and 1990s, I don't think there were many British Chinese women corporate trainers so I suppose I was a trailblazer, but never considered myself as one - as far as I was concerned I was just doing my job. So you and others who are younger and breaking new grounds are still the torch bearers and each breakthrough you make is important until we have more young British Chinese coming through who are confident about who they are and their abilities, and we have a critical mass of people who are in mainstream and influential professions.

We all have a part to play and we never should give up. I do my part by writing - not only for DimSum, but for my local newspaper and volunteering in the community in which I live.

Good luck with the BBC bites british born chinese experience competition. Let's hope that many young BBCs enter this competition and other competitions in the future.

Best,

Susan
Waiching Liu - RE: Susan S. Cheung Posted 12:37 on 16 February 2008
To Susan,

In response to your other comments, I would like to add that yes, I am aware that in the US, the Chinese population is therefore larger than the UK's. Primarily because America is a much bigger country and as opportunties in areas such as arts and entertainment are far greater for people from our ethnic group, which is why so many Chinese have either emigrated or were born there. Also,'The American Dream' concept is still alive and kicking for many Chinese who are labelled alongside, Japanese, Koreans etc as Asian Americans. Which is why in the US, race and wealth aren't huge factors that come into play as it is in Britain when it comes to employment and career choices.

In 2006, the Chinese Americans population was numbered approximately 3 milllion, followed by Canada with 1.3 million as of 2004 and Australia with under 700,000 in 2006. The UK's figure is around the 250,000 mark.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_Chinese

I suppose that it is indeed much more harder to break into the media and showbiz industries if you are Chinese in Britain, whereas it is a reversal in the US where you are American born Chinese, Japanese, Korean. etc. And perhaps it has got to do with the large numbers of Chinese emigrating and those of whom were born in the States.

Nevertheless, I am always encouraged to see the likes of Katie Leung making something of herself and appear in movies like Harry Potter, because to see her on screen and act as well as she has done, acts as a positive sign, not to mention proof that is possible for a BBC actress to make strides in an industry that is predominately white and male. Hopefully, she will carry on as an actress because Katie would be an ideal reference point for other young BBCs to look up to.

Btw, thank you for your kind words, in regards to me taking part in the BBC experience competition. I appreciate it a lot. And given i have studied Media in the past as a student, why not?

Regards
Waiching Liu
Billy Lee - the question of experience Posted 11:42 on 17 February 2008
I'm very interested to read reflections by Waiching and Susan about the British Chinese experience. At the age of 40 (41 next Saturday) I am not so young, but the struggle for an identity that makes sense of my dual-culture experience feels as fresh as ever, and I wanted to respond if only briefly.

I was also in London Chinatown and Trafalgar Sq. during last weekends new year celebrations, and I thought it was wonderful. In my identity confusion, I don't always celebrate chinese new year, and don't have regular chinese contact. But I don't remember any chinese new year celebration on the scale of that last weekend and I felt a rush of chineseness I've not felt in a while. I have nothing but praise for the organizers and participants. Back in Edinburgh now that sense of aliveness to who I am has faded somewhat and I feel back in my 'identity grey area'.

Perhaps combined with a 'mid-life crsis' my 'identity crisis' seems to be coming to the fore. My interest to visit china- always there but never strong, in particular ,is beginning to stir. As an academic (psychologist) of over 10 years I've mulled over a number of studies of experience. My latest idea is to carry out a study of the british chinese experience: to interview bbc's about their 'lived experience' and write an academic paper on my findings. I feel a little more inspired to start this after having read your reflections.
Waiching Liu - RE: Billy Lee- the question of Posted 15:14 on 17 February 2008
firstly, just want to say happy birthday for next saturday, Billy. Secondly, you mention that the identity crisis isn't just something the younger generation experience themselves, of which you're absolutely right. No matter what our age is, being British and Chinese is something we should celebrate more often, although there comes its drawbacks. But unlike the Chinese who were born indigenous, for Chinese Brits like ourselves, we know deep down what it is like to have two identities- a racial one and a nationality one. Because native Chinese and Hong Kong people are indigenous means they know what's like to be 'Chinese', they have lived in that culture throughout most of their lives to fully understand it properly. Unlike us but that is not to say it's a good thing or a bad thing. Also indigenous chinese from hong kong and China tend to assimilate and occupy themselves in an environment where the people they hang out with are Chinese, and not so much with say, Chinese Diaspora folk.

Personally speaking, I must admit that when I was at school and I was suffering racial taunts in the playground, it did make me question my identity. 'I am chinese, or I am British?' were playing in my mind. As I got older however, I realised that the reality was that there were so many BCs, as well as BBCs and so I wasn't the only one. Although I do have two younger brothers and a sister, and they too are BBCs.

I've been to Hong Kong twice and China once and yet i'll be visiting those countries during my 2/3 week break with my sister and parents. For some reason, I feel 'different'; my first language is English and my Cantonese is not all that great, and plus i cannot speak nor understand a word of Mandarin. but I guess some BBCs are in the same boat as me and feel the exactly the same way. So i'm not alone.

I hope your interview goes well and I will look forward to reading your studies on the BBC experience. Oh and the best of luck to you as well.

Regards
W.Liu
Susan S. Cheung - the question of experience Posted 16:37 on 17 February 2008
Dear Billy,

Welcome to the 40s properly as someone who is there already. I agree that hitting 40 brings up many issues, including our unique perspectives of being British Chinese and I agree with Waiching Liu that identity crisis can come at any age. I think we do examine and adjust at different stages in our life. I did big time when I married my husband - a fellow British Chinese and had my children and questioned how I bring them up with their identity. Please do read my other articles in the Features section about my experiences. http://www.dimsum.co.uk/features/

I also echo Waiching Liu that we are not alone and I have met other interesting British Chinese by reaching out. This is so much easier now with technology, unlike when I was growing up in the 70s and 80s when it did feel more isolated.

I would encourage you to go to China and take in that experience because you will always question until you've been. I would encourage you to do research into your experiences, which I think is part of one's growth into one's identity. I have learnt so much about what and how I think through planning and doing research for my writing.

We all have a choice to find out more. If we think there are gaps in our knowledge and having that will help with our experiences and confidence, then we can ask for information and help, and look for the knowledge within the Chinese community, through forums, such as DimSum and our own research.

I will be happy to speak more with you and you can email me at susan@dimsum.co.uk

Regards to you and Waiching Liu on this quiet Sunday (my husband has taken my kids out for the morning so I can have a break!)

Susan S. Cheung
pensggs Posted 1:04 on 18 February 2008
Having an identity without a pigeon-hole affect non UK born British Chinese too.

Being a British Chinese not UK born, does not make a person less British. An identity is a state of mind. Today, I am as passionately British as I am as proudly Chinese.

I find no 'conflict' in both identity. My Britishness is achieved by educational background, and growing up and my life experiences in UK. My Chineseness is achieved through by family upbringing and family values.
Both these values and my assimilation of these values make me who I am today. I am equally proud of both and equally at ease with both identity.
Waiching Liu - RE: Pensggs Posted 14:08 on 18 February 2008
Thanks for your reply to this subject. Judging by what I read, you seem to be comfortable and at ease about your identity and so you have no worries about finding out who you are and what you want from life. Unfortunately, there are some BBCs, particular the younger generation who seem to be slightly confused about their Chineseness and of whom are having difficulty juxtaposing their Western side with their Eastern roots. But like you mentioned, for you your eastern side is represented through your family, whilst your britishness is through the cultures outside of the 'home' environment, of which you are right.

Thanks again for your comment

W.Liu
kar - why media? Posted 12:53 on 18 February 2008
why does the success of BBC have to be portrayed in the media? does the success of BBC's need to recognised only when there is substantial coverage of us in the media?

.. many many many BBC are actually making their way through successfully and contributing into society. one which society actually does recognise! just because not too many BBC choose the career within media, it doesn't mean that we are under-represented. as for identity crisis, i believe that all depends on what direction one perceives things, as pensggs states, with those thoughts, identity crisis will be less of a problem - we BBC has best of both sides!
Waiching Liu - RE: Kar Posted 14:32 on 18 February 2008
To Kar

Well, to you it might be the case but how come we don't read about them or see them on TV? I cited the media because it is the main outlet for people expressing their ideas and in getting them across to audiences so that they can see what Britain is actually like. I like to know who these BBCs are because the impression I am getting from their 'non-existence' is that we don't exist and we are unheard of. Which isn't true. I personally would like to find out and know who they are. There are a few BBCs emnployed in the BBC and i'd like to know more about this because quite frankly, in the UK every minority group has a person or persons they look up to for inspiration. As far as I know of, I cannot think of a single BBC I can relate to.

Plus, the UK as portrayed in the media, is not reflective of the multi-cultural society that we are living in today.

As for the identity crisis, it all comes down to the individual and how he/she deals with the dilemma. If they are comfortable in their own skin by being Chinese and British, then really it isn't that much of a deal

W.Liu
pensggs Posted 18:44 on 18 February 2008
Once upon a time, I was lectured by a friend's father, about not forgetting that I am Chinese, wherever I might be. As he put it, even if I soak myself in a tub of acid, this would not change my skin.

Once upon a time, I was pulled up by a teacher who had spent his youth in UK, who told me that UK was not the paradise I read in my books. He informed me that I would not belong to any society, not the one I was born in nor the one I migrate to.

Both of them were equally right. However, one's success as a buman being is not about belonging or being accepted in any one society. First we must accept ourselves with all our folicles; then can we become a well adjusted part of any society we wish to belong to. It is about taking personal responsibilities for one's destiny, and not finding excuses for oneself.

The media in Uk is unfair, there is no doubt. However, look around you, there are examples of successful British Chinese everywhere, whose culture and values are respected by the people their life touches. The ripples of their life touches and influenced the society around them.

As China matures and gain respect in the world, British Chinese will become more comfortable with being Chinese and British at the same time. It is being bothered about how the British media's assumption and protrayal of 'chineseness' that can cause the 'identity crisis' in British born Chinese.
DC - CNY celebrations Posted 1:46 on 20 February 2008
i arrived late for the Chinese New Year celebrations in Chinatown & was disappointed by the show in Trafalgar Sq. Chinese New Year for me = loud fireworks, drums, lion dance outside restaurants/shops, the kind of things you would expect to see across HK/SE Asia. It's suppose to be noisy, bright & loud, welcoming the new year... not a organised march pass parade with police escorts starting from A - B followed by a stage show in Trafalgar Sq. If this is the way we celebrate Chinese New Year from now on, i'll be very sad indeed!

The fun or excitement of CNY from a family point of view is very similar to celebrating Xmas, it's the days leading up to it that makes it! the shopping, the house chores, the cleaning & cooking, the anticipation.. this makes it! For what happens on the 1st/2nd/3rd day onwards when you have to visit relatives(receive hong baos) or have relatives visit you(chances are you'll be giving them hong baos).. as most of us are into our 40s is a sign of how Chinese you are & if you still keep in touch with your Chinese relatives. And just like Xmas, there's always some fierce words & raised voices exchanged between old sparing partners, as they say blood is thicker then water, you can chose your friends but not relatives.. so be it, it's all good & part of the CNY festivities. For those who are younger & finding their feet & identity, try to find out more of your own family traditions, this is who you are & your peers/friends will respect you for that. A man with no family/roots is like a tree with no roots. As long as you can stand on your own 2 feet, no matter how small :) you're 1/2 way there!
Sara - BBC Celebration Posted 16:25 on 26 February 2008
I wrote this article many years ago as a celebration of being BBC and it was posted on the britishchineseonline.com site. I hoped it would inspire myself and others who have had a challenging hard time growing up.

http://66.111.36.90/pages/art23.html
Waiching Liu - RE: BBC celebration Posted 15:48 on 27 February 2008
To Sara

i'll check out your article and let you know afterwards what i make of it. thanks for the link

Waiching
Bevan Chuang - New Zealand Born Chinese Posted 23:15 on 28 February 2008
Hi all

I am from New Zealand and I would like to share with you a number of ideas too.
Although I am not a New Zealand born Chinese, I went to a conference in January, organised by the New Zealand Chinese Association, and it talked about the identity of New Zealand born Chinese (NZBC).

Chinese New Zealanders are working really hard to find out about their history, and to preserve our heritage. We know that many NZBC came from the goldmining era, the era which the New Zealand government wanted to put a Poll Tax on all the Chinese, and Chinese only, coming into New Zealand.

We know that the goldminers paid a lot of money to get themselves and their families to New Zealand so they can have a better life.

Our NZBC are very fortunate. The NZ Government had apologised to the goldminers and their decendents. We have set up a Trust to provide more resources to find out about our history and preseve our heritage.

The Chinese Association and the Trust also help provide support to young Chinese New Zealanders to excel in their field.

New Zealand is a small and young country. We do not have a number of internationally well known NZBC. However, there is a growing number of NZBC achievers, who are not only doing it for the Chinese community in New Zealand, but also in their chosen career field.

We had a New Zealand born Chinese Olympic atheletes; a well-known plastic surgeon, and a growing number of NZBC artists and film producers.

We are proud of them. We are proud to keep our heritage, and also succeed, as a mainstream New Zealander.
monkeyjai - identity Posted 17:51 on 3 March 2008
very good discussion, i think the identity issue will never go away because for BBCs there is no comfort zone of belonging. it not just about the BBC individual itself but also the other ppl around for not allowing one to be chinese or british.
natalie - looking for stories Posted 22:01 on 21 March 2008
Hello Waiching Liu,

I appreciate your article and have parallel sentiments regarding race and representation in the media.

I am a actress and filmmaker, born and raised in Canada to a Japanese father and Hong Kongese mother and have too found it challenging to find understanding amidst the content that is currently available.

I am looking to know more about the British Born Chinese community here in the UK and to find stories that are relevant to us in order to translate them to screen. Please contact me and I will be happy to speak further - this is our chance.

Best,
Natalie
nhigashi@mac.com
Write comment
Name:
Subject:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
Security Code:
Type the code in the image
(helps prevent spam)
Security Image
 
< Prev   Next >